Skip to main content
Fall gutter guards and window cleaning sale!
(519) 501-5003 Mon–Sat · 7:00am–7:00pm
Coal Tar vs Asphalt-Based Sealers: Which Is Better for Ontario Driveways?
Driveway Sealing

Coal Tar vs Asphalt-Based Sealers: Which Is Better for Ontario Driveways?

By Devon Moore November 9, 2024 5 min read

Coal-tar and asphalt-based sealers differ in formulation and handling. Canadian sales of coal-tar pavement sealants for domestic use are generally prohibited, subject to permit-related exceptions. Here is how the types differ and what to check before choosing a product for an Ontario driveway.

Share feedback

In This Article
  1. What each sealer is made of
  2. Head to head on seven questions
  3. Matching application to the product
  4. What changes on the day, and what does not
  5. Choose asphalt emulsion or acrylic-modified if
  6. Questions to ask before anyone opens a pail

What each sealer is made of

Coal-tar sealer starts with refined coal tar, a by-product of coke making, blended with water, mineral fillers and additives. It cures to a hard, flat black film.

Asphalt-emulsion sealer starts with petroleum asphalt, the same family of material as the pavement itself, suspended in water with fillers. Its film is usually a little softer to the eye and, in many makers' words, more flexible.

A third group blends acrylic polymers into either base, or sells acrylic-modified coatings on their own. The polymer changes dry time, colour and adhesion. In every case the water evaporates and the film cures on the surface, which is why weather and thickness matter so much.

Head to head on seven questions

QuestionCoal-tar basedAsphalt emulsionAcrylic-modified
Fuel and oil resistanceOften described as the stronger of the twoGenerally described as weaker against spillsVaries by product, so check the data sheet
Odour and handlingStrong smell, skin and eye irritation, gear is essentialMilder, though gloves and eye protection still applyUsually milder still
Environmental concernsHigh PAH content, the reason for the federal banMuch lower PAH contentDepends on the base it is blended with
FinishDeep, flat blackDark black or charcoalBlack or, in some products, colours
Cure speedSet by label and weatherSet by label and weatherOften marketed as faster
Availability and rulesSale banned in Canada since January 1, 2026, except under a federal permitWidely sold for home useWidely sold, but confirm it is for asphalt
Cold-climate flexibilityRead the data sheetRead the data sheetRead the data sheet

PAHs are polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, a group of compounds of environmental concern. The federal Certain Products Containing Toxic Substances Regulations generally prohibit sales of coal-tar pavement sealants for Canadian use after December 31, 2025, subject to permit-related exceptions, and also limit PAH levels in other pavement sealers. Ask the supplier to confirm the specific product’s permitted use and provide its safety data sheet.

Exact Price · Free Quote

Want your exact driveway sealing price?

Skip the guesswork, we quote your actual driveway, itemized line by line, free and no-obligation. Serving Kitchener, Waterloo, Cambridge & Guelph, with quotes ready within 1 business day.

Matching application to the product

Preparation, mixing, coverage and weather must match the actual product. The common driveway sealing mistakes are useful checks, but two coats are not universal: Henry HE200’s data sheet says not to apply more than one coat, while Black Jack’s FAQ describes two thin coats. Follow the selected product’s directions rather than adding a coat for reassurance.

Ontario adds one more factor. Freeze-thaw winters test the film at every crack and edge, so the label's temperature limits and the amount of curing time before frost count as much as the chemistry.

What changes on the day, and what does not

Read the selected product’s instructions for mixing, number of coats, coverage, application weather and reopening. Keep children and pets off for the required drying and curing period. Do not assume every sealer needs the same stirring routine or more than one coat.

The differences show up in handling. Older coal-tar products called for long sleeves, gloves, eye protection and good ventilation. Asphalt emulsions and acrylic blends are gentler, but they still stain skin, concrete and clothes, and a stray footprint can carry residue onto a garage floor or a walkway, where it is hard to remove. Whatever the type, protect the edges, wash tools as the label directs and never rinse them toward a storm drain.

If you would rather not handle any of it, that is a fair reason to hire the work out.

Choose asphalt emulsion or acrylic-modified if

  • Choose asphalt emulsion if you have an ordinary family driveway, want milder handling and lower environmental concern, and can keep the surface clear of spills.
  • Choose acrylic-modified if you want a quicker return to service or a colour, and the label says it is made for asphalt.
  • If fuel and oil resistance is the worry, for example a work truck that drips, ask for a coal-tar-free sealer rated for oil resistance, and clean spills quickly. If anyone offers you a coal-tar product, say no: it cannot legally be sold in Canada now, apart from narrow permit exceptions.

For a residential driveway, ask the supplier to confirm that the specific product may be sold for that use in Canada and provide its safety data sheet. The federal rules contain permit-related exceptions; a low-PAH description alone is not a guarantee of suitability near gardens, ponds, children or pets. Follow the product’s handling, runoff and reopening instructions.

Driveway sealing quote (from $450)Asphalt or interlock, size and condition.

Questions to ask before anyone opens a pail

  • Which product, of which type, and can I read its data sheet and safety data sheet?
  • Is it approved for asphalt driveways, and is it sold for residential use here?
  • How many coats, and at what coverage rate?
  • What does the label say about temperature, rain and reopening?

D&D Home Services gives free quotes for driveway sealing and confirms them in writing before work begins, so you can ask about the product and read the answer on paper. The asphalt versus concrete sealer guide covers what to avoid if your surface is not asphalt.

Key Takeaways

  • Coal-tar pavement-sealant sales for Canadian use have generally been prohibited since the end of 2025, subject to the regulations’ permit-related exceptions. Confirm the specific product’s permitted use with the supplier.
  • Asphalt-emulsion sealers are milder to handle with far lower PAH content, and acrylic-modified products are often marketed for faster drying.
  • Match preparation, coat count, coverage and weather to the selected sealer’s directions.
  • Ask for the product's data sheet and safety data sheet, and check what is permitted for residential use before you buy.
D&D Home Services
Devon Moore, Operations Lead Co-Founder & Operations Lead, D&D Home Services

Devon Moore is the co-founder and Operations Lead at D&D Home Services, with hands-on experience cleaning hundreds of homes across Kitchener-Waterloo, Cambridge, and Guelph.

Driveway sealing quote (from $450)

Asphalt or interlock, size and condition.

Get My Free Quote

Ready to Seal & Protect Your Driveway?

Sealing season runs through early fall, get your free, itemized quote before the calendar fills up. Serving Kitchener, Waterloo, Cambridge & Guelph.

Request serviceCall Now